Saturday, 5 July 2008

Doctor Who, Series 4, Episode 12: The Stolen Earth

"The Stolen Earth" was the best experience I've had while watching Doctor Who. It is not the best episode ever, but it is the most successful in giving the viewer a thrill a minute. It is the kind of episode that could only have been done now, at the end of the fourth series since Doctor Who was revived in 2005. There are tons of references to the programme's recent past, and a smattering of references to its older history too, most obviously in the return of one of the great villains of the past. I was eight when Davros first appeared in Doctor Who, in "Genesis of the Daleks", a story we re-watched this week in order to do a bit of homework ahead of his return in "The Stolen Earth". It stands the test of time remarkably well -- it is still very watchable, and Michael Wisher's Davros is brilliantly menacing. Julian Bleach puts in a fantastic performance as Davros in the new episode, and it is excellent that they kept his look pretty faithful to Davros's look from previous outings, and especially "Genesis of the Daleks".

There was a reward in this episode for those of us who have embraced not only new Who but also the rest of the new Whoniverse, with two series of Torchwood and a series of Sarah Jane Adventures. The fact that Torchwood series 2 went out also in a family-friendly version meant that Torchwood characters like Ianto and Gwen could be introduced here without the kids going, "huh?" And getting Sarah Jane Adventures into the mix too somehow grants that show too that extra bit of legitimacy. I like the fact that Russell T. Davies is proud enough of these new programmes to add them to a Doctor Who episode. There was something quite thrilling about having Gwen and Ianto, Sarah Jane and Luke (but I would have liked to have seen Maria too) in Doctor Who. And how did Russell manage to write a script with so much emotion, and so many characters, and without it feeling convoluted or rushed? It was not a convoluted story; it was easy to follow, and yet it sped along at a frenetic pace. "Oh great, more Wilf, yes! Oh, and Rose! Martha; is she dead? No, she's still alive! And there's Francine! Great! Harriet Jones!" And so on, all the way through.

My favourite review this week was from Behind the Sofa, by Neil:

Talkin' Bout Regeneration

. . . . . How can Russell top this? This isn't his last 'Horray!' by a long chalk - there's still four "specials" before his era truly comes to an end. So what on earth is he going to do for an encore? It's a terrifying prospect. How about the Doctor and Borusa riding in on the back of a Myrka to defeat Morbius, the Master and the Rani as they attempt to destroy ancient Gallifrey with the help of some Quarks? Guest starring Paul McGann and Sylvester McCoy (who has a Metebelis spider on his back) and featuring Simon Cowell as Himself. It's madness! Utter madness!

Good luck to him, I say. The audience is positively lapping it up and a stunning AI score of 91 won't see Russell changing tack as he hits the final stretch. We might as well go with the flow. This series has delivered some wonderful, thought provoking episodes - Midnight, Silence in the Library, The Fires of Pompeii - but we've always known that the finale would be an apocalyptic, loud, proud and utterly mental Russ-fest. Moaning about it now seems a little absurd. We may as well save our outrage for next week's obligatory reset button instead (aka the Haagen-Dazs Key).

Well, even if we get another "reset" or "rewind" in "Journey's End", I think I can cope with it for the joy of "Stolen Earth". I can't wait to find out how that cliffhanger is resolved and frankly, I just know that I can't be disappointed after such a fantastic 45 minutes. Heck, that "TO bam BE bam CONTINUED" was so thrilling that I wanted to watch it again and again. Although I can't wait for the resolution, I want to pause for a moment and enjoy this moment of not knowing, to make a memory here about how well cliffhanger TV works when it works, like it does here, with everyone going into a frenzy of speculation all week about what happens next. And of course that is my favourite clip of the week:



The test of a great episode is whether you want to watch it again, and again. We have already watched "The Stolen Earth" three times and would happily catch it again, except that it is almost time for the finale. Watching this episode was an extended Whogasm! I'd love to have seen those girls' reaction to this episode!

And now, it is media blackout time until we've seen "Journey's End".

Oh, five TARDIS groans, of course. Heck, I'd give it six.

Doctor Who Overdrive!

While we were enjoying the 4th of July, it seems that the UK media went into overdrive on the excitement generated by the last episode of the current series of Doctor Who later today, and not without reason. Last week's episode was such a fabulous, thrill-a-minute ride, especially for long time fans of the show, with the most exciting cliffhanger in the history of the show, that it is difficult not to be very excited indeed about the final episode tomorrow. I was delighted to read this round-up on Outpost Gallifrey:

Media round-up - UK in Doctor Who meltdown

The British media has gone into Doctor Who overdrive in recent days, with a frenzy of comment, speculation and analysis across all kinds of outlets on television, radio, the internet and in print. As the week has gone on the avalanche of coverage ahead of tomorrow's climactic finale to series four has continued to build, and the excitement shows no sign of dying down yet.

This evening, BBC One's main early evening news bulletin, the Six O'Clock News, carried a report from entertainment correspondent Lizo Mzimba, looking at the secrecy surrounding tomorrow night's episode. It featured a short new clip from the episode, as well as comments from Freema Agyeman - who said friends had been texting her about the series, and people on the street had been asking her about the episode all week - and Russell T Davies. Following the showing of the report, the weatherman commented that this Saturday's rainy weather would be suitable for staying indoors and watching Doctor Who! . . . .
Fantastic! I love "event television", telly that gets the nation talking, the family gathered in front of the telly! Bring on the rain! Bring on the finale! (We will be incommunicado to the outside world tomorrow just in case we accidentally catch a spoiler).

Friday, 4 July 2008

Thunder and lightning on the 4th of July

Out here in the US, we have been enjoying the 4th of July. Two years ago, Viola posted on our first Independence Day. Last year, we missed it because we were flying back from the UK, arriving in Washington DC late in the evening, and just in time to see a few fireworks in the sky as we drove home. Unlike that occasion two years ago, we didn't get the chance to go to the pool, but we did drive into Durham, and we spent an enjoyable afternoon with friends over there. We were back before dark, so we repeated our walk around the neighbourhood of two years ago and watched the fireworks which were being let off all over the place. Perhaps one of the first things one notices as a Brit doing this is the odd feeling of fireworks in the warmth of a July evening rather than the freezing cold of a November 5 in England. One also can't help noticing that people, at least round our way, are rather more cavalier on the safety issues than they are in the UK. The fireworks are let off in the middle of the road, and people just balance them on the road and walk right up and light them, and everyone seems to stand, and sit, pretty close. Mind you, didn't hear a single ambulance siren while we were out walking. But this year was dramatic because at about 9.30pm, a film-style thunderstorm began to develop, with forks of lightning, loud thunder and flickering lights in the sky of the kind that I used to think were just a film cliché before we moved here.

With the rain dampening everyone's fireworks, the evening's fun was over, and we returned home to catch the latest Big Brother eviction, a documentary about Abba and Mamma Mia and a discussion about how excited we were about tomorrow's final episode of this series of Doctor Who. On the latter, we have a plan of action to avoid accidentally hearing any possible spoilers between broadcast on BBC1 and our viewing an hour or so later. Oh, and it seems that SciFi Channel have a Twilight Zone marathon. It began very early this morning, and is still going on as I write. Could be a late night.

Thursday, 3 July 2008

Doctor Who, Series 4, Episode 11: Turn Left

And so we get to this year's "doctor-lite" episode. The doctor-lite episode is a means of filming a thirteen-episode + Christmas special series each year without it straining at David Tennant's schedule, allowing the crew to film two episodes at the same time. In the previous two years, the doctor-lite episode has also been companion-lite. "Love and Monsters" in the second series, penned by Russell T. Davies, was a hilarious celebration of the nerdy world of Doctor Who fans, here a group of individuals with a real-life fascination with the mystery of the doctor whose world was devastated by the "absorbaloff" played by the wonderful Peter Kay. Last year, the doctor-lite episode was the sublime "Blink", penned by Steven Moffat, the future show-runner, in what turned out to be one of the best episodes of all time, rightly rewarded with a BAFTA. This year, "Turn Left" was as different from "Blink" as " Blink" was from "Love and Monsters". Since Catherine Tate had already had her week off, in the previous episode "Midnight", another innovation, this year's doctor-lite for the first time became companion-heavy. This was Donna's episode, and it was a triumph. It now seems like an aeon ago since the nay-sayers were worrying about the choice of Catherine Tate to play the doctor's companion in this series (Not me!). Even Simon Mayo, in an interview with Freema Agyeman, felt obliged to stick in a dig about the choice of Catherine Tate as companion for the (then) forthcoming series. Well, Donna has been a revelation and even the nay-sayers have been won over.

This episode used a favourite idea of science fiction, and one already exploited in earlier series of Doctor Who, especially the second of the new era (2006), the parallel universe. But this was not the parallel universe of the second series but rather a new parallel universe generated by Donna making a fatal decision at a literal crossroads (well, a literal T-junction). It is the exploration of alternative outcomes that makes Sliding Doors and The Butterfly Effect such great films. But as so often, Russell T. Davies borrows a great idea but finds a way to exploit it in the context of a developing TV series -- he does things here that you can't do in film. It's one of the many reasons that I think RTD is such a great writer -- he understands contemporary television better than anyone. Unlike many writers, he does not see TV as the poor man's cinema. He loves TV, and finds ever fresh ways to do interesting things that are unique to the platform.

So here, the long-lasting TV series provides the invitation to reimagine its own recent past, to ask the question, what would have happened if Donna had not met the doctor back in the Christmas of 2006? What would the last eighteen months have looked like? Where Sliding Doors has to set up its own back-story within the first twenty minutes or so of the film, here we have had two series worth of back-story, the entire 2007 and most of the 2008 series of Doctor Who. So we don't need to spend any time on Donna's story over the last eighteen months. We already know all about that. The entire episode can look at what her life would have been like if she had turned right. And then, of course, this raises the huge issue that her meeting with the doctor had, in effect, changed history. And so we get this fantastic review of a life without the doctor and the devastation that it has brought. This is a doctor-lite episode in which the doctor is consipicuous by his absence. It reminds me of one of those ridiculous death-of-God sermons about how God can be tangibly absent. And I am already enough of a geek about new Who to find it dead exciting to see great moments from the last year and more revisited, but this time turning out so much worse, all the more so when these things are happening in the background, with Donna's traumas taking place as the key action.

Once again Bernard Cribbins was brilliant as Wilf, and Jacqueline King, as Donna's mother, was wonderful, and one of the most memorable scenes was her staring into the distance in the house in Leeds, completely forlorn, with Donna in soft focus behind her. The fact that the camera kept her in focus for seconds longer than we would normally expect brought home that this character was at her lowest ebb.

I haven't even mentioned the return of Rose yet, and I loved the fact that Russell T. Davies chose this way of reintroducing Rose to the series, an episode in which Donna was the star. Billie Piper whizzes into view in the credits at the beginning of the episode, but it is Catherine Tate we remember. Rose becomes an enigma, and we are looking for more in the next episode.

I loved every moment of this episode; the goose-pimple moments came at the end with Donna's willingness to travel in time, and Murray Gold's music here:



And yes, as many others have said, the beetle was crap, the only thing that detracted from a fantastic episode. My favourite review this week is on Behind the Sofa, Beetlemania by Iain Hepburn; excerpt:

This was a tremendous turn from Tate, as we see a very different Donna - one clearly undermined and almost downtrodden by her mother’s disappointment in her. Who remains wrapped up in her own little world, even as the rest of the universe collapses in around her. Donna not meeting the Doctor might have killed him physically, but it also killed her spirit.

Her finest scene in this episode? There’s so many to pick from, but for me it’s that moment when realisation slowly dawns, as the foreign family sharing the refugee home in Leeds is sent to a ‘labour camp’, what that actually means besides her own family having more room.
How can this be bettered in episode 12? Once again, a clear five TARDIS groans.

Doctor Who, Series 4, Episode 10: Midnight

And so we reach episode 10, in which we have an innovation. We are now used to the idea of doctor-lite episodes, with "Love and Monsters" in Series 2 and "Blink" in Series 3, but now we also have a companion-lite episode, in which Donna stays behind to sunbathe on Planet Midnight, in a sort of glorious Center Parcs on steroids, and the doctor goes off to enjoy himself in a shuttle with a small selection of other travellers, one of whom, Professor Hobbs, is played by Patrick Troughton's son David. The journey begins with every little piece of enjoyable light-hearted quirkiness that we have come to expect (and which I very much enjoy) in Russell T. Davies's scripts. But a third of the way in, everything goes pear shaped, the shuttle is under attack with some kind of strange knocking noise, and one of the passengers, superbly played by Lesley Sharp, appears to be inhabited by some kind of alien presence, stalking in the corner, imitating the patterns of speech of everyone on board, and ultimately learning how to speak in sync with the doctor:



I am a huge fan of Russel T. Davies, the person who, more than anyone else, is responsible for the revival of Doctor Who, as the show-runner since 2005. His reimagination of the series, character-driven drama with great story-arcs, always with homage to the past, has been a revelation over the last few years. And now he delivers one of his best individual stories since the revival. The vast majority of the episode happened in a tiny, confined space. It would make the basis for a great stage play. It demonstrates that what is great about new Who is not simply that they have a bigger budget, with proper special effects and no need for the wobbly sets that were part of the charm of the original series. This low-budget piece could have comfortably been filmed back in the 60s or 70s and would not even have strained their budget, with no dodgy prosthetics, no crappy mini-explosions. No, what is great about new Who is that the writing and the acting is just so compelling.

Its scare-factors were generated by three very simple ideas, all of which are carried off effectively because of the strength of the script and the quality of the acting. First we have the mysterious banging on the outside of the shuttle. That "knock, knock, knock" is a staple feature of some of the best spooky stories. It reminded me of Arnold Ridley's 1923 play, Ghost Train. When the banging starts, you begin to feel seriously claustrophobic. The second simple idea was the peculiar imitation of everyone's speech by Sky, then morphing into the lip-syncing with the doctor mentioned above. Russell T. Davies mentioned in this week's "Doctor Who Confidential" that the idea comes from the children in the playground, irritating people by repeating everything they say. Simple, but here, in this context, menacing.

And the third simple idea was to find ourselves as viewers becoming steadily more anxious as our hero is turned on by all the passengers. All those lines that usually work so well, where he is talking about how clever he is, attempting to take control -- all of these things worked so well on Christmas day last year, when he was with Kylie in "Voyage of the Damned" but here, suspicions built as fear increased. We find out just how difficult things become for the doctor when he does not have a companion. He actually needs that person by his side in contexts like this. As so often, Russell is exploring the very idea of the Doctor Who franchise, and stressing just how important the companion always is by illustrating the problems he has when he is alone.

Although a great free-standing episode, viewers find themselves reflecting on just how important Donna has become in his life, which itself sounds like the basis for another great episode, and one which will explore what will happen if Donna had never met the doctor.

This was one of the best episodes of the series so far, no question about it, and worth 5 TARDIS groans, bringing the series totals to the following:

Partners in Crime: 4 1/2 TARDIS groans
Fires of Pompeii: 3 1/2 TARDIS groans
Planet of the Ood: 4 1/2 TARDIS groans.
The Sontaran Stratagem / The Poison Sky: 3 1/2 TARDIS groans.
The Doctor's Daughter: 4 TARDIS groans.
The Unicorn and the Wasp: 4 TARDIS groans.
Silence in the Library: 5 TARDIS groans.
Forest of the Dead: 4 1/2 TARDIS groans.
Midnight: 5 TARDIS groans.

Wednesday, 2 July 2008

Doctor Who, Journey's End Trailer

I am behind on posting my comments on the fourth series of Doctor Who which ends on Saturday on BBC1. I want to get those comments posted over the next couple of days so that I can spend at least a little time gushing about the most recent episode, the penultimate one, last Saturday, entitled "The Stolen Earth". Just in case I don't get to that in time, before Saturday, let me just say here how much we loved "The Stolen Earth" in our house. It was a like a fairground ride, a thrill a minute, and the best cliffhanger in the history of the show (and please, if you happen to know how it resolves itself, no spoilers in the comments, thanks). So, to get us excited, here is the trailer for Saturday's 65 minute final episode:



Our two, Emily and Lauren, are so keen to avoid spoilers that they refuse even to watch this trailer lest it gives something away!

More gushing to come soon.

Tuesday, 1 July 2008

Watching Wimbledon in America

A couple of years ago, during our first summer in America, Viola and I both talked about our experience of watching Wimbledon here (Wimbledon and How to cope without British TV and Radio: Wimbledon Supplement). On the watching front, things are greatly improved since then. In fact, the coverage is excellent. We can watch the whole of every day's play in glorious high definition, alternating between NBC and ESPN2, even if the latter has an annoying ticker-tape thing that goes across the bottom of the screen the entire time, much of the time with incomprehensible material, in some kind of code, apparently concerning things happening in American sport about which we could not be less interested. The commentary is pretty good. We get a little bit of John McEnroe, but he is being paid more by the BBC, so Patrick McEnroe does much more here. Pam Shriver is great, and provides a bit of continuity for expats used to watching Wimbledon in England -- she was always a major feature of the BBC coverage in the past.

The oddest thing about watching Wimbledon here is being five hours behind. After three years here, this still takes some getting used to. At the moment, I get up and Wimbledon is already on while I am making a pot of tea. It's like it was back in World Cup 2002 (Korea and Japan) when we were watching football with our breakfast. Through the glories of the DVR, though, I have been able to delay watching until later in the day, so that the timing feels a bit more normal, and this has the added advantage of allowing the fast-forwarding of the endless ad-breaks. (People can criticize the BBC all they like, but try watching Wimbledon for a sustained period in the USA and its endless, endless bombarding of adverts, and it leaves you longing for the Beeb).

Of course one also misses the prioritizing of the few British hopes. In the first week we got very little of any of the Brits. But all that changed yesterday, at about 3pm our time, 8pm in England, as Andy Murray began a remarkable comeback in his fourth round match, turning around a two-sets down, 5-4 deficit, to win the third set on a tie-break, and then go on to win in five sets by about 9.30pm in England, 4.30pm here. We found ourselves wondering whether all the programmes on the Beeb had been delayed because of the excitement of Murray doing so well. And I could hardly believe how bright it still was at 9 in the evening. It's pitch dark here by then.

Suddenly, ESPN were all British enthusiasts and Sue Mott in the studio was going crazy. And there was a great moment earlier when Pam Shriver, sitting on Henman hill, interviewed a Scottish fan, while another painted a Scottish flag on her right cheek, with Pam pretending not to notice.

Tomorrow (Wednesday), we watch Murray losing to Nadal in the quarter finals. But at least well be able to watch him losing in high definition.